The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana

Tiger Times

The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana

Tiger Times

The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana

Tiger Times

Junior Sabrina Mari Alberty prepares for her solo during Sound’s “Kiss of the Femme Fatale” set at Spotlight Parent Preview Night. “Those extra practices really helped pull us together and refine everything so that it was ready,” Mari Alberty said. Parent Preview Night took place on Feb 1, 2024.
A shining silver spotlight
Gavin Auger and Emerson Elledge February 22, 2024

Black excellence in country music
Black excellence in country music
Katrell Readus, Opinion Editor • February 22, 2024

With Black History Month in full swing, controversy around Beyoncé's new country songs and my long-standing love for a good pair of cowboy boots,...

Classroom classics
Classroom classics
Riley McWilliams, Business Manager • February 20, 2024

Throughout a student's high school career, they’ll read a variety of books ranging from Shakespearean plays to thrilling novels. However, many...

Schedule psychology
Schedule psychology
Tanner Guillot, Reporter • February 14, 2024

Tanner Guillot is a senior and a reporter for the Fishers Tiger Times. His views do not necessarily reflect those of the newspaper.      Every...

Peeling back the layers of modern day animation
Peeling back the layers of modern day animation
Evie Briar, Sports Editor • February 14, 2024

Evie Briar is a junior and the Sports Editor for the Fishers Tiger Times. Her views do not necessarily reflect those of the newspaper.      The...

Pro-life and Pro-Choice students discuss ethics of abortion

Junior+Emma+Clemenz+answers+questions+from+junior+Lauren+Metz%2C+students+for+life+club+president%2C+during+the+debate.+Photo+by+Mo+Wood.
Junior Emma Clemenz answers questions from junior Lauren Metz, students for life club president, during the debate. Photo by Mo Wood.

Since its creation last year, the students for life club has received back lash for their views. However, the club opened its doors to pro-choice students juniors Emma Clemenz and Riley Crump to have an educated debate.

“We want to show that we are open-minded people, we’re not just like ‘we’re right and you’re wrong because that’s the way it is,'” debate organizer junior Sarah Maarouf said.

Wednesday Feb. 15, the members of the students for life club met in H223 and listened to the argument presented by their pro-choice friends. Clemenz and Crump spoke on the safety of abortion clinics, the number of illegal abortions compared to legal, the medical ramifications of an abortion, Planned Parenthood and its services and  the relevance of brain activity and a fetus’ ability to support itself outside of the womb.

After the girls presented their information, they invited the pro-life club to ask questions. The group went back and forth over topics such as when is a human truly alive and when does it have personhood, reasons for bringing life into the world, safety of the mother and fetus during abortions and many other topics.

The two sides conflicted mainly on when life begins, the pro-lifers agreed that life begins at conception, while Clemenz and Crump argued 28 weeks, when a fetus can support itself outside of the womb.

The debate ended on friendly terms, as the students for life club applauded Crump and Clemenz.

“I think it [the debate] helped me see the other side of why they think the way they do and why I still hold my own beliefs. It helped me understand their opinion but it also helped me form my own,” Maarouf said.

 

Leave a Comment
More to Discover

Comments (0)

Join in the public forum.
All Tiger Times Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Activate Search
The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana
Pro-life and Pro-Choice students discuss ethics of abortion