The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana

Tiger Times

The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana

Tiger Times

The student news site of Fishers High School, Fishers, Indiana

Tiger Times

Players of the volleyball team practice at the Fishers New Aux Gym on May 16, 2024. Cameron Benson (second from the right) and junior Davis Theobald (far right) worked to receive the incoming serve from the other side. Photo by Vi Tran.
Fishers Boys Varsity Volleyball Gears Up for State
Vi Tran, Reporter • May 24, 2024

Two-time state champion Tigers were able to place first at sectionals and regionals after competing throughout the season. As the team prepares...

1890s postcard of the University of Berlin (now called the Humboldt University of Berlin). The school’s founder, Wilhelm von Humboldt, implemented a novel educational model at the university, which emphasized holistic, curiosity-driven learning, rather than exclusively vocational, market-driven learning.
The case for holistic education
Jakob Polly, News Editor • March 15, 2024

In November of 1942, Congress lowered the minimum draft age to 18. Anticipating fierce Axis resistance in North Africa, Europe and the Pacific,...

Happy campus, happy academics
Happy campus, happy academics
Kate Charters, Reporter • February 28, 2024

    When choosing a college 99 percent of the time students are searching for good academics rather than focusing on what the college campus...

Junior Sabrina Mari Alberty prepares for her solo during Sound’s “Kiss of the Femme Fatale” set at Spotlight Parent Preview Night. “Those extra practices really helped pull us together and refine everything so that it was ready,” Mari Alberty said. Parent Preview Night took place on Feb 1, 2024.
A shining silver spotlight
Gavin Auger and Emerson ElledgeFebruary 22, 2024

Black excellence in country music
Black excellence in country music
Katrell Readus, Opinion Editor • February 22, 2024

With Black History Month in full swing, controversy around Beyoncé's new country songs and my long-standing love for a good pair of cowboy boots,...

Keyword search: full Eras Tour movie

How imperfect social media algorithms make ‘camcording’ more common than ever
Free+seats+in+movie+theater+photo%2C+public+domain+leisure+CC0+image.
rawpixel.com
Free seats in movie theater photo, public domain leisure CC0 image.

    Though copyright law might seem to some like a modern-day issue, it has been around since the 1700s in the United States. Even if it was more limited than the ones we have today (only protecting books, maps and charts for 14 years) it shows a deep-seated care for the protection of original work. However, with the relatively recent accessibility of pocket-sized recording technology, breaking these laws seems easier than ever. This is especially true for someone who does not know what the exact laws are or what they apply to. 

   Taylor Swift: The Eras Tour, which debuted Oct. 13, is a professionally recorded and edited film comprising several performances during Swift’s tour. This is not by any means a new concept; however, it is one of the most popular concert films to date, grossing $96 million domestically on its opening weekend. This means it now holds the record for the Top Music Concert Film of All Time, according to Billboard.com. This has left some confused on how to treat a concert film. After all, people could record during the actual concert, perhaps they would be allowed to record in the theaters too. But how much recording would be considered ‘too much?’ Sophomore Lyrie Tzarfati, a self-proclaimed “huge Swiftie” and attendee to both the concert and film, thinks that a non-disruptive amount of recording should be okay. 

    “It’s fine to film a little bit if theaters allow it,” Tzarfati said. “I know the AMC I went to didn’t mind if we filmed, but I don’t think excessive filming should be allowed as it takes away from the movie experience and can be very distracting.”

    Other fans disagree with this sentiment. Junior Maggie Garner said that they do not see the point of recording the film in the first place.

    “I don’t think people should film in theaters, obviously,” Garner said. “Since the Eras Tour has so many videos taken from the concert…I don’t exactly see the point of even wanting to film the movie when you could just look online for a live video.”

    This disagreement likely comes from the ill-defined nature of copyright laws themselves. There is no public-friendly way to access every copyright law relating to recording within a theater. So, various people just resort to whatever their theater tells them is okay. For example, Tzarfati’s experience of being told it is okay to film. However, a What To Know Before You Go page on the AMC website directly contradicts her story.

    The website states, “Feel free to take selfies and group photos, but you may not record the concert film on our big screen.” Which may lead anyone in Tzarfati’s group to even more confusion about what is allowed. 

    The recording of any portion of the film displayed within a movie theater is illegal. However, even this is less than clear because there is no law on how much (whether that be the number of pixels or duration) of a film must be ‘pirated’ before it is considered copyright infringement. The reason there is no law surrounding it is that it is generally decided in a courtroom. In order to avoid copyright lawsuits, most social media apps have a terms and conditions page that contains information on their intellectual property policy, which every user agrees to with the download of the app.

    TikTok’s policy states that “we do not allow any content that infringes copyright. The use of copyrighted content of others without proper authorization or legally valid reason may lead to violation of TikTok’s policies.” Violation of these policies usually results in the removal of content and the suspension or termination of an account.

   X (formerly Twitter) and Instagram have similar policies, yet a simple search of something like ‘Eras tour movie’ will lead to several videos that likely violate copyright law. According to the policies of these apps, these videos should have been removed, yet they have not. This could be due to a variety of things: a poor copyright-detecting algorithm, a complete lack of a copyright-detecting algorithm, a lack of reports of stolen content, or an insufficient response to reports. The problem some have with the uploading of ‘camcorded’ content is that it discourages people from seeing the movie and supporting the copyright owner. Others do not see the issue and think it even encourages them to see the full film.

    “I think it has the capability to do both,” Tzarfati said. “If people see a short movie clip on TikTok or Instagram, for example, it might encourage them to go see it. However, if someone posts the whole movie, it would lead to people just watching the movie illegally and unsustainably.”

    Overall, with all the confusion about what is and is not legal, perhaps it is better to leave the filming to the cinematographers.

View Comments (1)
More to Discover
About the Contributor
Evie Briar
Evie Briar, Sports Editor
Evie Briar is a junior at Fishers High School. She enjoys playing guitar, writing, listening to classic rock music and playing in the schools symphony orchestra.

Comments (1)

Join in the public forum.
All Tiger Times Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • G

    GretchenNov 3, 2023 at 1:04 pm

    Omg i love Taylor Swift shes amazing
    This article was great
    10/10
    Write more about Taylor Swift

    Reply